|
Textbooks: |
 |
 |
Davis,
Robert Con, and Ronald Schleifer eds. Contemporary Literary
Criticism: Literary and Cultural Studies. 4th ed. New York:
Longman, 1998. ISBN 0-8013-3002-5 |
| Murfin,
Ross C., ed. The Scarlet Letter. By Nathaniel Hawthorne.
Case Studies in Contemporary Criticism. Boston: Bedford-St.
Martin's, 1991. ISBN 0-312-03546-2 (You will need this specific
edition of The Scarlet Letter as we will discuss the critical
essays included in the book.) |
 |
|
Recommended Text: |
 |
 |
Harmon,
William and C. Hugh Holman. A Handbook to Literature.
8th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1999. ISBN 0-13-012731-0 |
|
Course Objectives: |
 |
As the title of
the course suggests, we will examine the theories and methodologies
behind several different approaches to literature, so that you will
have a broader range of critical techniques to call upon as readers,
students, scholars and teachers.
One of the most
important criticisms that arises from courses like Approaches to
Literature is that it lacks a thorough examination of the practical
applications of the various approaches discussed. The texts we are
reading, though they are often the best articulation of the theoretical
basis of the critical practice they espouse, usually deal in abstraction,
referring to specific literary texts only occasionally and elliptically.
To counter this problem, I have scheduled a practically-applied
text from each of the six approaches we will examine. Thus, after
discussing two theoretical texts on "Structuralism and Semiotics,"
we will look at Louis Marin's "Disneyland: A Degenerate Utopia"--a
semiotic reading of the structure of Disneyland. Because it is a
text that many English majors have read, I have chosen Hawthorne's
The Scarlet Letter as the literary touchstone for the class.
Thus, everyone will be expected to read this novel prior to the
four-week classroom session. You will need to have the edition specified
below, since it contains the critical texts we will discuss.
|
On Reading Literary Theory: |
 |
The actual number
of pages that you are required to read for this course may be less
than those required by your other graduate courses. However, I urge
you to read the texts for this course before we begin the four-week
classroom session as these texts are among the most difficult in
our field. You may find some to be virtually unintelligible. Even
so, do yourself the favor of slogging through them ahead of time,
taking copious notes. When you understand an author's point, make
a note in the margin. When you can't grasp the author's point, write
a question in the margin. The majority of our classroom time will
be spent addressing students' confusions and concerns with the texts.
In his essay "On
Difficulty" George Steiner identifies four forms of difficulty apparent
in contemporary literary criticism. The first--contingent difficulty--stems
from readers' unfamiliarity with the terms and references. You can
overcome this difficulty rather easily by consulting the optional
text for this course--A Handbook to Literature. The Handbook
is like the ultimate footnote. Most of the unfamiliar words, terms,
and names you will encounter are explained in the Handbook. The
second form of difficulty--modal difficulty--comes from readers'
lack of experience with abstract literary theory. Modal difficulty
fades with time. The more of these texts you read and the more we
discuss in class, the less modal difficulty you will encounter.
The other two forms--tactical and ontological difficulty--are an
inevitable effect of the ambitious and admirable effort to examine
news ways of looking at literature and culture. Tactical difficulty
refers to the authors' efforts to disrupt the readers' accepted
world view, whereas ontological difficulty refers to the cultural
gap between authors and readers--as Schleifer and Davis write in
the "General Introduction" to Contemporary Literary Criticism:
"[T]rying to see and feel the world from a perspective other than
one's own--perhaps through the eyes of women, or members of ethnic
minorities, or people subject to colonialism" (15). The best way
to deal with these difficulties is to read the introductory sections
of both Contemporary Literary Criticism and the critical
section of The Scarlet Letter. If, for instance, you have
difficulty with Stanley Fish's "Interpreting the Variorum,"
look at the introduction to "Rhetoric and Reader Response" in CLC
and "What is Reader-Response Criticism?" in SL. (For a more
detailed discussion of Steiner and "On Difficulty" see pp. 13-16
of CLC.)
The emphasis in
this class will be quality over quantity. If we need to skip some
texts to ensure that we have enough time in the classroom to discuss
other texts to your satisfaction, so be it. Nevertheless, the best
favor you can do for yourself is to begin the reading early, working
through these texts as best you can, obtuse and annoying though
they may be.
|
Grading: |
 |
Your grade for
this course will be based on a final essay of twenty-five to thirty
pages. In this essay you will examine a single literary work from
the perspectives of three of the approaches discussed in class (the
bold headings on the schedule below).
|
|

|
|

|

|
The Syllabus.
The
tentative schedule of the course, detailing readings, assignments,
exams and any other class activities.
|
 |
|
|
|

|

|
The Files.
A collection of required and recommended files and documents to download
for this course. Currently, the only file here is a printable version
of the syllabus and course description. |
|

|
|

|

|
E-Mail Me.
Send me an e-mail.
|
 |
|
|

|

|
English Department.
Back to the English
Home Page.
|
 |
|
|

|

|
Fort Hays State University.
Back to the FHSU Home
Page.
|
|